A spread of delicious food dishes
ice cream

Best Ice Cream in Indianapolis, Indiana

Ranked by 1 community votes for 2026. FoodMedals members award Gold, Silver & Bronze medals to their favorites.

#1
Handel's Homemade Ice Cream
7125 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN
Gold14 pts

Also Popular in Indianapolis

🍔Best Cheeseburgers🍛Best Indian Currypad thaiBest Pad ThairamenBest Ramen🍣Best Sushibbq ribsBest BBQ Ribs
🏆

Think we're missing a spot?

Award your own Gold, Silver & Bronze for Ice Cream in Indianapolis.

Award your medals for Indianapolis