Best Ice Cream in New York, New York
Ranked by 15 community votes for 2026. FoodMedals members award Gold, Silver & Bronze medals to their favorites.
As of May 11, 2026, Taiyaki NYC Japanese Ice Cream leads the ice cream rankings in New York, New York with 17 points from community votes, followed by Soft Swerve Ice Cream at 9 points and Anita La Mamma del Gelato at 7 points.
Looking for the best ice cream in New York? FoodMedals tracks 3 restaurants across New York, New York serving ice cream, with 15 community votes cast in 2026. Taiyaki NYC Japanese Ice Cream currently leads the 2026 rankings.
4
1
2
Also Popular in New York
🏆
Think we're missing a spot?
Award your own Gold, Silver & Bronze for Ice Cream in New York.
Award your medals for New York