Best Ice Cream in Buffalo
2026 Community Rankings
Scoops, soft serve, sundaes, and shakes
NYBuffalo, NY
2026 Community Favorites
Loading map...
🏆
No medals awarded yet
Be the first to vote this year!
Community Nominations
Suggest a restaurantNo pending nominations for this category. Suggest one!
Settle the Debate: Who Has the Best Ice Cream?
Grab your friends, pick 3–5 top-ranked spots from the leaderboard, and do a ice cream crawl. Rate each stop, compare notes, then come back and award your medals.
Pick Your Lineup
Choose 3–5 spots from the rankings above
Rally the Crew
Text the group — the more opinions, the better
Award Medals
Vote Gold, Silver & Bronze after you taste-test
Free to vote · Change your picks anytime · New rankings every year