Best Milkshakes in Buffalo
2026 Community Rankings
Thick, creamy, classic and over-the-top
NYBuffalo, NY
2026 Community Favorites
Loading map...
🏆
No medals awarded yet
Be the first to vote this year!
Community Nominations
Suggest a restaurantNo pending nominations for this category. Suggest one!
Settle the Debate: Who Has the Best Milkshakes?
Grab your friends, pick 3–5 top-ranked spots from the leaderboard, and do a milkshakes crawl. Rate each stop, compare notes, then come back and award your medals.
Pick Your Lineup
Choose 3–5 spots from the rankings above
Rally the Crew
Text the group — the more opinions, the better
Award Medals
Vote Gold, Silver & Bronze after you taste-test
Free to vote · Change your picks anytime · New rankings every year