S
ShortNorthDesserts
Food ScoutColumbus, OH
10 pts3 medals2 categoriesSince 2026
Crown Jewel
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams
Ice Cream · Columbus, OH
Your Crown Jewel pick earns this restaurant a bonus point on the leaderboard.
2026 Trophy Case
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams
Columbus, OH
the Brown Butter Almond Brittle at Jeni's has this caramelized depth that makes it the most complex ice cream I've had. The Short North flagship is the original and still has the best rotation.
2nd Place
Awaiting pick
3rd Place
Awaiting pick
Fox in the Snow Cafe
Columbus, OH
Fox in the Snow in Italian Village makes daily donut specials based on what the kitchen feels like doing. The chalkboard tells you what's there. The kouign-amann is excellent if they have it alongside.
Buckeye Donuts
Columbus
3rd Place
Awaiting pick