Eddie and Sam's NY Pizza

Serving downtown Tampa since 1998, Eddie and Sam's imports water from New York to replicate the mineral content that distinguishes authentic New York pizza dough. Wide, foldable slices with thin crispy crusts and a long fermentation tang have earned over 1,500 Yelp reviews, and Tampa Magazine named it a Best Pizza winner in 2025. The corner location on Twiggs Street has operated continuously for more than 25 years.